Lack of Pedestrian infrastructure turns the Delhi’s roads to be the deadliest

Dear Friends,

“Priority for the Pedestrians”  is a policy that all developed nations have adopted unequivocally for they consider every life important. Its not that Indian cities do not value the lives of their citizens but the pedestrian policy is just missing. On the other hand its the Car and other personal vehicles that get advantage over pedestrians.

Many argue that it is because those who make policy are car users and while making policy the general public is not consulted. But today the awareness is growing. Not only there is a need to discipline the traffic and orient them with “Pedestrian first” policy but also the pedestrian need to be disciplined.

However, the general argument put forward is that if there is no pedestrian infrastructure and roads are being continuously widened to accommodate the vehicles, where do the pedestrians go?

The rising number of accidents and majority of them being the pedestrian indicates the repurcussions of not having a pedestrian friendly infrastructure in place. The recent news report below sums up the death figures from National Crime Records Bureau.

regards

Svayam Team

Delhi’s Roads are the Deadliest

Delhi is the most unsafe city in India for pedestrians, government records show. The latest ‘Accidental Deaths and Suicides in India – 2008’ report of the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) says as many as 589 pedestrians were crushed to death on the Capital’s roads in 2008.

More people die on Delhi’s roads than any other Indian city of comparable size; in fact, Mumbai, with 3.6 million more people than Delhi, has only around half the number of road fatalities – 302.

So widespread is the problem of road accidents and deaths in the Capital that pedestrian fatalities outnumber murders (528 in 2008).

Overall, road accidents, including those involving two-, three- and four-wheelers, claimed 2,098 lives.

Which means close to 30 per cent of all road accident fatalities were pedestrians – nearly four times the national average of 8.7 per cent.

It is not just vehicles that kill pedestrians in Delhi. In 2008, open pits and manholes claimed 21 lives, the report says. Two-wheeler accidents accounted for 554 deaths on Delhi’s roads, while 151 people travelling in fourwheelers died in 2008.

Delhi is geographically much smaller than Tamil Nadu, Karnataka and Gujarat. But in terms of the number of accidental deaths on the roads, Delhi is close to them. The pedestrian death figures for Tamil Nadu, Karnataka and Gujarat are 662, 591 and 640 respectively.

More alarmingly, the report states, Delhi accounted for 29 per cent of all pedestrian deaths recorded in 35 Indian megacities that have a population of one million or more.

For instance, only 52 pedestrians died in Hyderabad in 2008, 74 in Bangalore, 29 in Pune, 62 in Jaipur and 71 in Nagpur for the same period. Chennai, Kolkata and Ahmedabad were the safest cities in India for pedestrians – not a single death was recorded in these cities in 2008.

The NCRB report shows that nearly a third of the deaths occur in the six- hour period between 6 pm and midnight, making pedestrians vulnerable at night.

Nationally, though, most road accidents take place between 3 pm and 6 pm.

A Delhi Traffic Police official said the remarkable increase in the number of cars in Delhi and the shrinking space for pedestrians is partly to blame for rising road accident deaths.

The NCRB report cites statistics provided by the ministry of road transport and highways – Delhi had nearly 4.5 million motor vehicles as on March 31, 2008. This figure has only gone up since.

Drivers are indisciplined too, the official said. According to the Delhi Police, 2.12 lakh people were caught for over- speeding in 2009, and another 6.17 lakh were caught jumping traffic lights. An unbelievable 12,109 drunk drivers were penalised in 2009.

Drink driving is another issue that the Capital is grappling with; it is a problem that claimed 2,165 lives in 2009, a Delhi Police official said. An NCRB official said it has information that pedestrian fatalities in Delhi are further up in 2009.

Dr S. Gangopadhyay, director, Central Road Research Institute, feels pedestrian facilities in Delhi leave much to be desired. “In developed countries, pedestrians are given the top priority,” he said.

“This is missing in Delhi. There are zebra crossings but most people don’t use them, most signals do not work. Worse, rash driving leads to high pedestrian deaths.” There are other faults that Delhi has, he said. Delhi may have constructed subways and foot- overbridges (FOBs) for pedestrians, but security inside the subways – especially for women – is a problem after dark. “Several pedestrians, including most women, refuse to use them due to security issues,” he said.

Rohit Baluja, president, Institute of Road Traffic Education (IRTE), said Delhi is a plain case of “near negligible” pedestrian facilities leading to the high fatalities.

“If there are adequate pedestrian facilities for safe walking, the casualties will come down,” he said. “Footpaths in Delhi do not support carefree walking as they are encroached upon mostly by parked vehicles. Hence, the pedestrian is forced to walk on the carriageway and risk his life.

Wherever pedestrian crossings exist, drivers don’t respect them.” He added: “At cross paths where there are no traffic signals, pedestrians have the right of way, but no one respects it. It is unfortunate that the government too has given emphasis only on motor transport and not to pedestrians.” Baluja said with the Commonwealth Games fast approaching, Delhi’s pedestrian facilities would be put to the test once the thousands of foreign tourists arrive.

“We are building pedestrian facilities now only because of the Games, while other countries do not wait for a mega event to something as basic as this.”

Qutub Minar proves Accessibility is Good Business Sense!

After Qutub Minar bacame accessible and more friendly to every one, the footfall has gone up in last two years despite the slow down in the economy! Article is silent on the reasons which are obvious! Who says Accessibility is not a Good Business Sense?

Here is the news report from Mail Today:

Click here to read from source

 Qutub Minar rakes in moolah for Delhi

Pratul Sharma, New Delhi, March 3, 2010

According to figures presented by the culture ministry in the Lok Sabha, revenue earned through ticket sales at the Qutub Minar stood at Rs 10.41 crore, much higher than that collected for the Red Fort (Rs 5.5 crore) and Humayun’s Tomb (Rs 4.8 crore) for 2009.

While the other monuments received fewer footfalls because of a drop in tourist numbers, thus affecting their revenue generation, the Qutub Minar was the only building that collected more revenue than the previous years.

It saw an increase of close to Rs 85 lakh in revenue in 2009, than the year before.

The revenue for the UNESCO-designated other World Heritage Sites – the Red Fort and Humayun’s Tomb – dropped during the same period.

The Qutub Minar’s revenue earnings are second only to the Taj Mahal’s – whose revenue share also dipped.

The Taj earned Rs 14.87 crore in 2009, a drop from Rs 17.42 crore during the previous year.

Moreover, it seems Delhi was the preferred tourist destination, over even the Taj Mahal.

No wonder the Qutub Minar, the highest building in the country, raked in the money.

Being a well- preserved building with a collection of smaller monuments within the main complex, it offers more attractions to the visitors.

They are awed by the sheer beauty of its carved stones and the imposing height of the tower.

With the economic slowdown hitting tourism, revenue generation at world heritage monuments fell drastically last year.

The overall figure for revenue earned through entrance tickets at 16 centrally protected monuments during 2009 was just Rs 50 crore, as compared to Rs 66.84 crore in 2008.

The drop in revenue showed the fall in the number of foreign tourists visiting the country.

Sources said foreign tourists contribute more as each ticket for them costs Rs 250 as compared to Rs 10 for tourists from the SAARC nations.

Monuments in the country that saw a marginal increase in revenue through ticket sales last year were the Ellora Caves ( Rs 1.21 crore), the Buddhist monument at Sanchi ( Rs 1.94 crore), the Sun Temple in Konark ( Rs 1.8 crore), the Elephanta Caves ( Rs 80 lakh) and the Champaner- Pavagarh Archaeological Park ( Rs 13 lakh).

Congratulations to ESG and BITS Pilani for their successful efforts in making Film Festival Venue Accessible

Dear Friends,

Congratulations to Enertainment Society of Goa to have made the venue of Annual Internal Film Festival disabled friendly and also to those who facilitated and handholded the process.

News Source: Net Indian, Appended below is the detailed news.

regards,

Svayam Team

ESG honoured for making IFFI venue disabled-friendly

February 15, 2010

The Entertainment Society of Goa (ESG) was honoured here recently for making the venue of the annual International Film Festival of India (IFFI) disabled friendly. The honour was bestowed on the ESG at the We Care Film Festival on Disability here by its organisers, the BITS Pilani Goa Campus, Brotherhood, the National Trust, United Nation Information Centre, UNESCO, and Asian Academy of Film and Television of India (AAFT) in association with the local organizations Sangath and Disability Rights Association, Goa .

The recognition was received on behalf of ESG by its General Manager Venancio Furtado, who appreciated the objectives of the We Care Film Fest and its participatory rating process. He gave an assurance that the ESG would be happy to associate with the We Care Film Fest in the near future.

The festival, which travels to educational institutions to create greater acceptance of the differently-abled as part of mainstream society, witnessed the screening of 32 documentary and short films on various forms of disability from India and overseas. The festival is travelling to around 15 venues in the country over the next three months. It has introduced a participatory rating process in which the students and the audiences rate each film and an indepent jury judges the films on the basis of these ratings.

BITS Pilani Goa Campus Director K E Raman appealed to the students to think about the various issues of persons with disabilities and make use of their knowledge to promote their rights as set out in the various acts like PWD Act, the National Trust Act and UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with disability which came into force on May 3, 2009. He said BITS had been organizing various national-level cultural and other educational events in its Pilani, Goa, Hyderabad and Dubai centres, but it was the first time that it had organized a festival on disability issues. He promised that BITS would continue to support the We Care Filmfest and take it to other centres of BITS as well.

Mr. Avelino D’Sa, President of the Disability Rights Association of Goa, welcomed the holding of the We Care Fimfest in the state and said the event would be taken to various corporates, State Government departments and owners of shopping malls to sensitize them on disability issues.

Mr. Vishram Gupta, Chairperson of Sangath Goa, said short films are very effective in sensitizing general public, students, children and persons with disability and their parents. He said the festival would be taken to schools and other educational institutions of Goa .

We Care Filmfest founder Director Satish Kapoor said: “a world that truly embraces diversity is one where the rights, dignity, and well-being of individuals are realized regardless of differences in race, faith, gender – or ability. People living with disabilities often surprise us with their abilities, with what they can do rather than what they cannot do, but not many tell their stories.” He said the festival was an opportunity for all students to develop their understanding and perspectives relating to disability issues besides contributing to the process of participatory rating. This would help the students whenever they plan to make short films/documentaries on disability. It would also help sensitise the general audience on various issues of disability, he said.

Source: http://netindian.in/news/2010/02/15/0005343/esg-honoured-making-iffi-venue-disabled-friendly

Access in public infrastructure remains neglected

Dear Friends,

Inaccesss to built infrastructure, roads, pedestrian infrastructure  and public transportation are becoming tools of oppression, discrimination and marginalisation when it comes to disabled and the seniors.

India needs to gear up to the needs of the elderly and the disabled in terms of its infrastructure at the earliest if it doesn’t want to loose out on tourism opportunities, hosting international events of any kind and above all if it wants to escape bashing by activists due to its lackadiasical attitude towards monitoring implementation of access in the infrastructural projects in the present scenario.

India is at the thresh hold of development. Major cities are grappling with the problems of managing public transportation. Sustainability and accessibility can go hand in hand if State thinks in inclusive terms for all its citizens.

It was evident from the recent difficulties faced by international athletes who  were here in Bangalore to participate in “International Wheelchair and Amputee Sports World Games” that India is hosting. The athletes faced problems bnt in track and field, but in gaining access to the stadiums, hotels, transport systems and public places around Bangalore. 

The answer lies in ensuring that all properties, infrastructure and  transporation system that are created henceforth is accessible and inclusive to all to avoid such embarrassment to the nation. This will also make the country more equitable and inclusive to the elderly and the disabled citizens.

Here is the report from Indian Expresss

Here is a different report form Times of India

regards

Subhash Chandra Vashishth

Now another heritage site, Maquinez Palace, Panaji becomes accessible

Dear Friends,

Maquinez Palance, Panaji has become another Heritage site to become accessible, this time with the efforts of Goa Disability Rights Association and the Govt’s pro-active support to provide accessibility.

Congratulations to Mr. Avelino D’Sa, The President of DRAG and his team for their perseverence and achieving this success in making yet another site accessible to all!

Here is the coverage, To read from source click here.

regards

SC Vashishth, Program Coordinator, Svayam

Maquinez palace gets lift for disabled

PANAJI: Chief minister Digambar Kamat on Thursday inaugurated a special lift for specially challenged people at the Maquinez palace, Panaji.

The lift will help specially challenged people to view movies in the two theatres in the Maquinez palace during the upcoming International Film Festival of India.

Talking to the media after inaugurating the lift, Kamat said, “The facility will benefit disabled persons and specially challenged children to gain access to the theatres in the Maquinez palace. Specially challenged persons were demanding the installation of this lift and now they are satisfied. It will give them an opportunity to watch movies here.”

Avelino D’Sa, president of Disability Rights Association of Goa (DRAG), also expressed satisfaction at the installation of the lift. “We have been fighting for this for a long time. It is not only during IFFI that we come here, but we attend functions all through the year. INOX is also being made disabled friendly,” D’Sa said.

D’Sa said other government buildings, streets and buses are still not made disabled friendly and that DRAG was working to bring about changes there. Officials from Graand Prix elevators, who installed the special lift at a cost of Rs 19 lakh, said the lift is aesthetically better than normal lifts and can be installed without making any structural changes to the building. This was especially important in Maquinez palace as it is a heritage building.

Svayam’s Efforts bore fruits: Hotels to become disabled friendly

Dear All,

Svayam’s association with Min. of Tourism has finally brought some positive indications. After institution of Award for “Most accessible Tourist Destination/Hotel”,  now Ministry of Tourism has revised its guidelines for hotel classification making it mandatory for all classes of hotels to facilitate access and stay for visitor with disabilties.

Svayam had conducted first workshop on Accessible Tourism for Min. of Tourism, Govt. of India on 23 October 2008 which was well received by the then Secretary Tourism-Mr. S. Banerjee, IAS and the participants included Architects, Engineers and Officers from MOT, Tourism departments of various states, State tourism development Corporations and ASI etc.

Later, Svayam hosted a Conference on Accessible Transportation and Tourism in Delhi during March 2009 wherein the Secretary Tourism had inaugurated the Conference and declared that MOT will not release grants to any project unless accessibility for the disabled visitors was included as an essential feature in the project.

Besides this, Svayam has been involved in a regular exercise of training Owners of Budget Hotels/Guest Houses in and around Delhi on Facilities for guests with disabilities and those with reduced mobility in the hotels. These workshops are being conducted at IHM, Pusa on an ongoing basis to cover all hotels around Delhi in a phased manner through a joint initiative of MOT, Govt. of India  and Licencing Branch of Delhi Police.

Svayam is also a member on Core Committee on Accessible Tourism constituted by Min. of Tourism, Govt. of India It is also a member on TAC (Technical Advisory Committee) to conduct a Research Survey in India on Status of Inclusive Tourism.

Svayam provided detailed guidelines to MOT during the first workshop held in October 2008 which have now been included in to the Ministry guidelines for hotel classification.  A  manual on How to make a hotel/Restaurant Accessible to all that intends to help Hospitality Industry by providing detailed guidelines to make their services and properties accessible to all, was uploaded on Svayam website and is available to all for free downloading.

This has been only possible due to pro-active approach followed by Min. of Tourism, Govt. of India and committed support of Svayam. We congratulate Min. of Tourism on this initiative.

regards

Svayam Team

Here is the news article on the subject:

Hotels to be disabled-friendly Nandini R Iyer,

Hindustan Times , September 2010,

A disabled person will be able to check into any hotel classified between One and Five Stars with relative ease. The Tourism Ministry has revised guidelines for hotel classification making it mandatory for all classes of hotels to facilitate basic access and stay for disabled people. In addition, some more facilities have been made mandatory for Three, Four and Five Star hotels.

All hotels higher than ground plus two floors will have to have a 24×7 lift and where local laws do not permit this, establishments will have to provide “easy access for differently abled guests,” say the new guidelines.

Each hotel classified between One and Five Stars will have to have at least one room for disabled guests. These rooms will have to have a minimum door width of one metre for wheelchair access, low height furniture, low peephole, cupboards with sliding doors and low clothes hanging rods. The guidelines require that such rooms have audible and visible (blinking lights) alarm systems.

Compliance is mandatory by September 1 next year. A most basic facility, which India’s disabled community has been fighting for — ramps with anti-slip floors — are also mandatory now. The ministry has insisted that in Five Star and Five Star Deluxe hospitals there must be free access to all public areas and at least one restaurant.

These two categories of hotels will also have to provide at least one telephone for public calls at a height of two feet. All hotels have been told to provide wheelchair-friendly bathrooms with “suitable fixtures like low wash basin, low height toilet and grab bars”.

Public restrooms will have to have low height urinals in all hotels. All hotels will need to have wheelchairs available to disabled guests free of charge and provide “exclusively earmarked parking facilities nearest to the entrance for disabled guests”.

Disability Advocates demand access to Bus Depots in Gujarat

Gujrat has taken lead in developing socially inclusive infrastructure like BRT and Metro and the pace of growth is quite remarkable. However, it necessary that the existing bus Q shelters are also retrofitted with barrier free features to enable passengers experiencing disabilities to use these services on an equal basis with others. Also the existing fleet needs to be gradually replaced with accessible buses with proper access from Bus Depots and Q shelters.

Gujarat has set successful examples of Public private Partnership and there is no reason why PPP can be availed to improve accessibility at GRSTC BUS Depts!

regards

Subhash Chandra Vashishth

Click here to read from source

Funds crunch makes GRSTC bus depots disabled-unfriendly
29 Jun 2009, 0049 hrs IST, TNN

Gandhinagar : Of the 125 Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation (GSRTC) bus depots in the state, facilities for the physically-challenged at 104 are missing. A slope which is mandatory at each bus stop to facilitate the differently-abled board the vehicle comfortably is not in place.

GSRTC officials say it is the dearth of funds which a big hurdle in providing such facilities.

The matter was taken up recently by the Disability Advocacy Group during a meeting with RM Patel, principal secretary, labour and employment department, who also holds the additional charge of disabled commissioner. The representatives of the group demanded that there should be an adequate arrangement for the physically-challenged to get into a bus easily and get down from them as well.

During the meeting, PK Patel, chief traffic & commercial manager, said there were slopes at 21 bus depots for the physically-challenged. He added at the remaining 104 depots, there was no provision for slopes and fund crunch was a big hindrance. The commissioner directed GSRTC to allocate funds and set a deadline for making slopes at all these depots.

Pradeep Anjaria, a commuter, said, “The buses are designed in such a manner that it becomes difficult for the physically-challenged to get inside them. The entrance of these buses are L-shaped and hence they cannot board the bus easily.”

He said in absence of a slope, one has to first lift the physically-challenged person and take him on the platform and then take his wheelchair in. They also find it difficult to get into a bus as there is no separate lane for them to board a bus.

Ranjit Gohil, who was present at the meeting, said, “The physically-challenged are provided host of facilities in many countries. But in India, laws are not enforced properly. One needs to ensure implementation of these laws without fail.”

Gohil said the situation of the railways is no better. He has filed a complaint against the railways stating that it does not have any facility for physically-challenged passengers to move from platform 1 to 12. He said there is a slope for entry to platform 1 only. The lifts which are installed at the platforms are mostly out of order, he pointed out.